The argument is descending into one about the definition of "crap theory."
I have a low bar for crap theory. As long as it doesn't have evidence that confidently supports it, it's crap.
The other guy has a high bar for crap theory. A theory without any evidence, to him, is not crap.
It's like arguing over what temperature is hot and what temperature is cold. Pointless. An Eskimo has a different definition of cold and hot then say some guy who lives in a desert. Put them in the same place and let them debate about whether the current temp is hot or cold... That argument ends up being an argument about vocabulary. What is the definition of hot or cold?